Sentience Sapience
and the apparent lack of either in most writers |
| This
is a bug bear of epic proportions, mainly because it has so filtered into
the media that it is literally IMPOSSIBLE to create any kind of sci-fi
without making this basic elemental blunder. The problem is that these two words do NOT mean the same thing, and the word SENTIENT is used pretty much exclusively where the word SAPIENT is required. http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=sentient http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=sapient Now, these two seem similar, but they're very different. Virtually
every life form is sentient. Basically anything that can tell that it
is different from other things around it has sentience. Mice are sentient
life forms because they can sense that they're being prodded and know
that it is by something that is not them. They understand that object
A is a worm and can be eaten, and object B is a rock and cannot. They
understand that both A and B are not part of itself. Now every time I hear someone on a sci-fi film or series ask something like 'Is there any sentient life?' they would be far better asking 'Is there any sapient life?' because the chances are very good that what he's really trying to find out is if there are any creatures down there we can talk to and get stuff from. The amount of times that question gets asked and the answer is 'No' followed by the cast wandering around whilst various critters waft around is staggering. Two mildly relevant points; sapient creatures are by definition ALSO sentient, but the reverse is most certainly not true. The reason why we have the scientific classification Homo Sapiens is simply because we are the ONLY specie on this planet capable of the kinds of abstract thought that warrants being sapient. If one day we show that dolphins or chimps are also then they would be reclassified, probably something along the lines of 'Ceta Sapiens' or, er, 'Munky Sapiens'. It drives me batty. Hopefully after you've read this you'll become massively intolerant of this same gratuitous misuse of English and campaign vocally for the mistake to never be repeated. |